U4GM - 5 Online-Only Items You Can Get Through Elden Ring Multiplayer
Elden Ring is well-known for its rich single-player content, but its multiplayer features open the door to a unique set of experiences—and rewards. Whether you're invading, helping others, or simply exploring cooperative gameplay, several Elden Ring Items are available only through online interactions. These items are not just rare—they often symbolize your journey through the game's social landscape.
Having played Elden Ring since launch, I’ve delved into both PvE and PvP worlds. Some of my most memorable moments—and most elusive loot—came from multiplayer. If you're considering jumping in or checking the safest site to buy Elden Ring items, here are five online-only items worth hunting (or helping) for.
1. Furled Finger’s Duelist Furled Finger & Finger Severer
When you start engaging with multiplayer, one of the first tools you'll need is the Furled Finger. But the Duelist Furled Finger is unique to PvP dueling, allowing you to lay down a red summoning sign to challenge others. Using this, and the Finger Severer to cancel your summon, is the foundation of your PvP toolkit.
In my case, the first time I used it was in front of the Colosseum in Leyndell. That duel taught me more about the game than hours of PvE. While the item isn’t strictly gear, it's critical—and only obtainable by venturing online.
2. Bloody Finger
This item permanently allows you to invade other players’ worlds, and it’s unlocked through an online-involved questline with White Mask Varre. While technically some of the early steps can be done offline, the final invasion at the Rose Church requires online access.
When I followed Varre’s path and completed my first real invasion, I felt a rush of excitement and tension. Earning the Bloody Finger changed how I approached Elden Ring forever—it was like unlocking a new layer of the game.
3. Duelist’s Furled Finger Rewards (Including Rune Arcs)
Participating in duels can earn you Rune Arcs and other items depending on the mode you choose, especially after the Colosseum update. These Elden Ring Items boost your stats significantly while using Great Runes.
I used to stock up on Rune Arcs through PvE farming, but after a few evenings in the Colosseum with friends, I found PvP to be a faster (and more engaging) method. Plus, the duels sharpened my skills and introduced me to new builds I wouldn’t have tried otherwise.
4. Warrior’s Cookbook [6]
This one surprised many players. The Warrior’s Cookbook [6], which lets you craft certain PvP-useful items, can only be obtained through successful invasions. This cookbook enables the creation of items like Roped Fetid Pots—essential tools for aggressive PvP builds.
If you’re uncomfortable with invading others, I suggest summoning into friendly duels first. Once I got used to that, I ventured into invasions and found them surprisingly rewarding (even when I lost). And yes—I got the cookbook and used it to make my next battle loadout far more fun.
5. Eyes of Yellow
Dropped by defeating invaders during the Frenzied Flame invasions, these eerie items are PvP trophies, similar to how Eye of Death worked in previous FromSoftware games. They don’t serve a crafting purpose but act as a symbol of conquest or survival. Only online players can participate in this type of event, making these items truly exclusive.
In one session, I was invaded three times back-to-back near the Frenzy-Flaming Tower. I only survived twice, but earning the Eyes of Yellow felt like a rite of passage. To me, it’s one of the more honorable badges of Elden Ring multiplayer.
Multiplayer in Elden Ring is not just an afterthought—it’s an entire layer of gameplay with its own exclusive progression, systems, and rewards. From duelist tools to PvP trophies and crafting manuals, these Elden Ring Items offer meaningful value to players who explore online features.
If you’re worried about missing out or struggling to keep up with seasoned PvPers, there are also resources like the safest site to buy Elden Ring items for those looking to supplement their builds or catch up quickly. Just make sure you’re dealing with a trustworthy platform.
From my own experience, multiplayer made Elden Ring feel alive. These items aren’t just loot—they’re memories of battles won and lost, of friendships forged in co-op, and the thrill of the unknown. Whether you’re a veteran or just starting out, don’t miss the chance to see what Elden Ring’s multiplayer world has to offer.
Just Released: Ultimate Guide: How to Securely Purchase Elden Ring Runes in 2025